Subscribe to VETERINARY PRACTICE NEWS   SUBSCRIBER SERVICES    Bookmark and Share
VPN Logo   
 Home   About Us   Contact Us
6:08 AM   April 16, 2014
Your E-mail:
 

 
Bookmark and Share
Titers Join Debate on Vaccine Frequency

By Jessica Tremayne

For clients, vaccines are part of routine pet care and for the most part, veterinarians can expect owners to comply with vaccine reminders and schedule an appointment.

While the visit serves as an opportunity to examine the pet for other maladies, one thing is certain: The pet will be vaccinated before it leaves.

Some veterinarians maintain that administering core vaccines every three years or even annually is outdated and isn’t practicing good medicine. While practitioners argue that liability or a patient contracting a virus outweighs the risk of a potential vaccine reaction, critics interject the titer argument.

“Few veterinarians are proactive about discussing the options clients have in protecting their pets against disease,” says W. Jean Dodds, DVM, founder of Hemopet, a non-profit veterinary blood bank in Garden Grove, Calif. “The industry promotes more vaccines and veterinarians feel comfortable telling clients they’re necessary. Often, technicians have vaccines prepared before the doctor even examines the animal. Many vets don’t know how to handle titers or don’t want to bother with them.”

Vaccine experts liken the three-year protocol to that of children’s vaccine regimens, which have come under public scrutiny after accusations that they cause  autism. Although all veterinarians agree vaccines are necessary, the frequency in which they’re given is debated.

“Veterinarians need to administer the rabies vaccine as defined by law, but other core vaccines for canine distemper virus, parvovirus and canine adenovirus-2, are administered needlessly,” says Ronald D. Schultz, DVM, PhD, Dipl. ACVIM, professor and chairman of the pathobiological sciences department at the University of Wisconsin, Madison’s School of Veterinary Medicine.

Titer Results
“Challenge tests and titer levels have shown animals to have strong immunity to these viruses five, seven, even 10 years after the vaccine was given,” Dr. Schultz says. “Animals died of old age before they needed to be revaccinated in those studies.”

Schultz participated in the vaccine task force that created the American Animal Hospital Assn. guidelines. AAHA canine vaccine guidelines make suggestions on titers and also say to vaccinate “no more than every three years” with core vaccines.

Schultz says veterinarians often read this as meaning the vaccines should be given every three years without question. Additional concern revolves around the physical condition an animal presents in and is still given vaccines as usual.

“Practitioners often don’t understand the value of titers and therefore don’t relay that to the client,” Schultz says.

“Also, titers are too expensive for most clients. Titers aren’t necessary for all vaccines, just distemper and parvo. Vaccines given annually for diseases such as leptospirosis and kennel cough should actually be given more frequently (at least annually) because they’re not as powerful as the core vaccines. Distemper, parvo (canine and feline) and adenovirus have 99 percent effective immunity and caliciviris and herpes virus vaccine have 60-70 percent effective immunity. Many of the animals given those core vaccines will have a lifetime of immunity.”

Manufacturers
While drug manufacturers say they don’t disapprove of titer testing, they’re leaving the promotion of the procedure up to vets and predict the higher cost of titer testing opposed to vaccinating will discourage clients from agreeing to a titer test.

“A small portion of the population may have a reaction at the injection site or an anaphylactic reaction,” says Tom Lenz, DVM, vice president of professional services at  Fort Dodge Animal Health of Overland Park, Kan.

“Vaccines are pretty accurate the way they’re labeled. These reactions have nothing to do with the frequency as to which the vaccines are given. Only about 50 percent of the animal population is vaccinated, for many reasons, one of which is cost. Clients won’t likely be interested in paying maybe three times as much for a titer.”

Dr. Dodds questions why pet vaccines are given with such frequency when vaccines for measles and polio aren’t given to adults.

Exam Reminders
“Instead of sending reminder cards for vaccines, veterinarians should be sending annual wellness exam reminders,” Dodds says.

“When vaccines are needed, they shouldn’t be given at the same site or at the same exam. Banfield Animal Health released two papers on this topic saying animals weighing less than 20 pounds and receiving combo vaccines are at the highest risk of vaccine reaction, yet few DVMs arrange separate visits as a precaution.”

Others say reducing vaccines to less than a three-year frequency would raise more questions about outbreaks of currently tamed viruses.

“People tend to forget that infectious diseases like distemper, parvovirus and others are deadly for those dogs that are not protected against them,” says Ulrike McCray, DVM, marketing director for companion animal health at Schering-Plough Animal Health.

“While these infectious diseases are rare among dogs and cats, it’s because they’ve been vaccinated,” Dr. McCray says. “If we reduce vaccinations in dogs and cats, the infectious diseases will return. Antibody titers are not always a reliable indicator for the level of protection necessary for a dog or cat; it’s more reliable to follow the recommendations of the label.”

On the Horizon
Schultz and a veterinary diagnostic company are designing a user-friendly titer test that could be used in-house, giving fast results and costing less than current testing methods.

“We project a 2010 release of the titer test, but it still must gain USDA approval,” Schultz says. “We hope the test will be used instead of immediately revaccinating an animal, but it wouldn’t need to be performed more often than every three years, or every five years.

There’s no reason to go from over-vaccinating to over-testing, although no adverse effects would come from drawing blood.”

Vaccinating less often is a concept trying to gain momentum, but it has been a concern to some for decades.

“It can be scientifically proven that not vaccinating can cause harm to an animal, but vaccinating per label suggestion has not been shown to be harmful,” Lenz adds. “Considering an animal’s likelihood of exposure, age, health and breed are some things veterinarians should consider before giving vaccines. I think some vets are very good at doing this while others are not.”

Dodds disagrees, saying just about anything can go wrong when a vaccine is given, from lethargy to death.

In a 2000 paper published in JAVMA, Dodds documented 1,400 cases in which more than 97 percent of the dogs tested had good immunity from vaccines given 10 years earlier.

“Vaccines are largely safe, and are intended to improve the health and welfare of animals,” Schultz says. “But when problems do occur and the animal didn’t even need the vaccine, that’s unacceptable. I would like to see more puppies and kittens vaccinated with the core vaccines because there are many that never get vaccinated. However, I would also like to see those that get vaccinated not receive core vaccines more often than is necessary and to only receive those non-core vaccines that provide a benefit.” <HOME>

Related Online Exclusive:

Holistic Approach to Vaccination

 Give us your opinion on
Titers Join Debate on Vaccine Frequency

Submit a Comment

Industry Professional Site: Comments from non-industry professionals will be removed.

Reader Comments
This is a great article, I am determined not to give my small dog the rabies vaccine again (or any vaccine for that matter). I am willing to do the rabies titer.
She is being treated for allergies and is currently on prednisone, if my vet doesn't sign the rabies vaccine waiver...I was wondering someone could elaborate on "flying under the radar?
If I were to send my dog to live with relatives in N.H. (I live in Mass.)
That would be okay?
L, Boston, MA
Posted: 1/19/2013 7:53:45 AM
I totally concur with Dr. Dodd's concerns and recommendations. Years ago we had our Sheltie pup receive a 5-in-1 vaccine and she developed a severe, life-threatening reaction. It was afterwards that I started researching the subject and came across Dr. Dodd's site. Now we titer our Shelties after they turn 3 years old and only vaccinate when indicated.
Susan, Crofton, MD
Posted: 11/19/2012 11:29:47 AM
I love it! Fantastic!
But I want to know why we still vaccinate our animals after the initial vaccines are given? Why has none of the vets I talk to realized this information and stopped annual or even 3 year vaccines?
I would love to see what would happen if they were told they had to go in for annual vaccines for the rest of their lives...or maybe their children!
Annual vaccines need to stop! It's just fear in the public that makes them believe it is necessary!

Is there anything I can do as part of the public to bring this subject back to life?
Dawn, Indianapolis, IN
Posted: 2/17/2012 8:29:12 AM
I will get a Rabies titre on my now rescue dogs, because I have had 6 out of 7 (plus my now two rescue dogs=9 dogs).

My dogs--

a. young?--Sept.,1979 to May,1984 (5)

b. heart disease--Nov.,1981 to July,1988 (6 1/2)

c. double heart disease--May, 1988 to October, 1996 (8 1/2)

d. anemic disease--July, 2002 to May, 2008 (5 3/4)

e. aggressive behavior (bit me badly)--April, 2008 to February, 2010 (21 months) BECAUSE OF TWO RABIES SHOTS (4 1/2 months and again at 19 months)

f. spinal disease/ruptured disk—glaucoma (both eyes)--incontinence-low thyroid--April, 2000 to March, 2010 (9 3/4)

g. knee bones rubbing together (both knees-a month apart of each other) August 13th, 1996 to present (14 1/2)

I now have two rescue male Springer Spaniels (3 yr.(rescued Jan., 15, 2010—birth-Sept. 14, 2007) and 2 yr.(rescued March 16, 2010—birth-Jan. 5, 2009) and I am NOT getting yearly vaccines (shots) that are not necessary.

My boys WILL get titer tested.

I DO NOT want to get the rabies vaccine (shot) at all anymore. This vaccine has hurt all my dogs in different ways. I have heard the rabies vaccine is good for 5 to 7 years.

My 3 year old Springer is due for his Rabies shot next January, 2012. I want him to be Rabies tested so I do not have to get him the Rabies shot next January, 2012.

It really makes me sick to have read/researched all about the Rabies vaccine and other vaccines side effects. It has made me cry for my other dogs that have gotten sick/died.

My beautiful 3 year old Springer is a very happy therapy dog. People just love him. I do not want him or my other rescue Springer dying young.


Sincerely,

Judy Chimner
Judy, Macomb, MI
Posted: 3/22/2011 1:52:13 PM
View Current Comments

Click here to subscribe

Subscriber Services

See all veterinary videos
Featured Vet Grooming Video 
Video Button
Facebook
BROUGHT TO YOU BY Veterinary Practice News

Copyright ©   I-5 Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved.
Our Privacy Policy has changed.
PRIVACY POLICY/YOUR CALIFORNIA PRIVACY RIGHTS.
Terms of Use | Guidelines for Participation

Gold Standard

*Content generated by our loyal visitors, which includes comments and club postings, is free of constraints from our editors’ red pens, and therefore not governed by I-5 Publishing, LLC’s Gold Standard Quality Content, but instead allowed to follow the free form expression necessary for quick, inspired and spontaneous communication.