In the horse world, the common garden hose is virtually indispensable. A good, firm jet of cool water run vigorously over a fresh cut, a swollen limb, or a large deep wound at the very least makes a person feel as if something important is being done for the horse.
There are many undeniable advantages to using a garden hose for wound lavage.
1) A firm stream of water can certainly help remove surface debris that can contaminate a wound. Removal of debris in this way is effective, less time-consuming, and less tedious than removal of wound debris with a forceps or gauze sponge.
2) Using a garden hose has the advantage of simplicity. In general, something that is easy is also more likely to get done.
3) Lavaging a wound with tap water from a hose is reasonably safe. Understandably, many horses don’t like to have their wounds handled. For many horses, a lavage fluid that could be applied at a distance would be an attractive alternative to inspecting a wound up close.
However, given that water coming out of a hose is neither sterile nor isotonic, it is not unreasonable to wonder if garden hose water is actually a good option for wound lavage. Large volumes of hypotonic fluid could theoretically be harmful to tissue. That’s because with hypotonic solutions, there is a higher concentration of water outside the cells. As such, there is a net movement of water from outside to inside the cells, from regions of lower solute concentration to regions of higher solute concentration. At least theoretically, irrigating tissue with hypotonic solutions could cause it to become waterlogged, and thus impair wound healing. In addition, some may feel irrigating a wound with tap water would lead to microbial auto-contamination and bacterial resistance.
What’s on tap?
Perhaps surprisingly, in human medicine, there have been quite a number of studies investigating irrigating wounds with tap water in a number of settings. This may come as something of a surprise, given all the technical advances in medicine; however, researchers investigating wound healing have actually devoted a lot of time and attention to the use of tap water as a wound-irrigation fluid.
There is no evidence tap water is harmful to wounds; studies have failed to show differences in infection rates of wounds irrigated using either tap water or sterile saline solution. In fact, researchers identified a trend toward fewer infections in wounds irrigated with tap water when compared to wounds irrigated with sterile saline. In addition, a number of studies conducted in hospital emergency rooms have concluded that rinsing out wounds with tap water works just as well as using sterile saline.
Human research also indicates that skin wound irrigation with tap water leads to a greater reduction of Gram-positive bacteria compared with 0.9 per cent sodium chloride sterile solution. In that same study, no difference was shown between tap water and sterile saline in colonization of hemolytic bacteria, Gram-negative bacteria, and fungi.
Chronic wounds also may benefit from tap water wound irrigation. Chronic wounds of the horse’s limbs can be difficult and expensive to treat, and can cause a tremendous amount of anxiety on the part of the horse owner. One factor in the persistence of chronic wounds is the presence of bacterial biofilms within organized wound beds. Even in dentistry, use of tap water for lavage has strong indications. In human dentistry, water is a very accessible, cost-effective irrigant without apparent side effects. In humans, irrigation of the surgical site of third molar removal with tap water using a curved syringe has been shown to be effective in reducing the risk of inflammatory complications and associated morbidity. As such, running a garden horse in a horse’s mouth may be a cost-effective and scientifically sound way to provide tissue irrigation, when warranted.
On a broader note, it is also interesting to consider that, in human medicine, there is limited evidence aggressive cleaning of wound surfaces actually does much to prevent wound infections. Not that removal of wound debris is unimportant, of course; however, excessive attention to cleaning wound surfaces prior to wound repair does not seem to result in better healing outcomes. Recommended irrigation pressure of around 13 psi can be easily obtained using a garden hose and is effective for cleansing wounds without causing tissue trauma.
Of course, with fresh wounds, the use of tap water from a garden hose should be applied after hemorrhage has stopped. Aggressive hosing of a bleeding wound can impair the clotting process. Let the bleeding stop, and then use the hose.
David W. Ramey, DVM, is a Southern California equine practitioner who limits his practice to the care of performance and pleasure horses. Visit his website at doctorramey.com. Columnists’ opinions do not necessarily reflect those of Veterinary Practice News Canada.