A look at evidence-based spay/neuter recommendations

Ultimately, we need to weigh the risks against the benefits of spaying early. More importantly, we need to inform owners of these concerns and involve them in the decision-making process, rather than using a one-size-fits-all approach.

little chihuahua with rottweiler in front of white background
GettyImages/cynoclub

As veterinarians, we must adjust our client recommendations and clinic protocols based on current medical evidence. For some subjects, we can rely on veterinary guidelines developed through a thorough review and synthesis of the veterinary literature, which provide unbiased scientific recommendations. Unfortunately, we are not always that lucky and sometimes have to review the literature ourselves or make decisions based on specialist recommendations and consensus statements. Reproductive health is no exception.

When I first started in veterinary medicine (many years ago), we basically made a blanket recommendation that all pets be spayed or neutered on or before six months of age, and for females before their first heat. As research advanced, however, drawbacks emerged in large and giant breeds desexed before full bone/sexual maturity. Now we are seeing more research showing certain breeds may carry a higher risk of certain neoplasias if spayed early; large and giant breeds may carry a higher risk of orthopedic injury (e.g., cranial cruciate ligament [CCL] tears) with early desexing, and more.

Ultimately, we need to weigh the risks against the benefits. More importantly, we need to inform owners of these concerns and involve them in the decision-making process, rather than using a one-size-fits-all approach, at least for our canine patients.

What this article isn't about

Desexing can be accomplished in dogs and cats via surgical methods, gonadectomies, and hormonal methods, including implants. A review of the literature on the negative effects of hormonal implants was not performed because the focus was on gonadectomy, the most common method of desexing/population control in the U.S.1 Note: Gonad-sparing surgeries are not discussed in this article.

However, this is not a discussion on the means of gonadectomy specifically. I will not cover techniques; instead, I want to focus on the timing of spaying and castration (neutering will represent both terms moving forward), pros, cons, and the client education that should precede developing a protocol for your hospital, rescue, shelter, or even your own animals.

How to perform a spay, neuter, or even a partial gonadectomy, such as an ovariectomy, is not the issue of concern with the medical evidence. It has recently come to light that early spaying and neutering, while the benefits for population control seem obvious,2–4 may have unforeseen negative effects in some breeds, possibly based on the animals' size and growth rates.

What are the current best practices and recommendations? Can we truly make this distinction based on the current available evidence and evidence synthesis? What about our feline friends?

What we know

Gone are the days when we simply want generalized recommendation to neuter all pets at six months of age without discussing with owners the possible downsides to not permitting dogs, for example, from going through at least their first heat due to risks of certain orthopedic conditions or neoplasias with early neutering. Shelters and mass neutering for population control is a different situation, where there are outright public and animal health concerns. In private practice, when we are discussing the individual animal and the best way to preserve the human-animal bond (HAB), we owe it to our clients to review the evidence that is increasingly becoming apparent about some of the negatives of early neutering.

What we know is limited based on available research and synthesis to date. However, we know a few things.3–11

  1. Spaying prevents pyometra.
  2. Neutering prevents benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) (or, if present, can help reduce some, if not all, of the effects over time).
  3. Neutering can help reduce overpopulation (e.g., consider shelter overcrowding, stray cat populations).
  4. Neutering can lessen the risk of excess roaming in dogs (greater for males than females)
  5. Desexing often leads to overweight/obese animals (though the age of gonadectomy in cats seems to have less effect on this occurrence than in dogs). However, while we know metabolism can slow by up to 30 percent12,13 with desexing, it falls on the veterinarian to properly educate owners that feeding requirements will decrease after neutering. By educating clients up front they will need to feed less, monitor weight, use measuring cups, skip the table scraps, and switch from puppy/kitten to adult food at a certain time, we can help prevent obesity. With proper client education, we can avoid overfeeding pets.
  6. Spaying dogs before the first heat cycle can prevent mammary cancers. However, research suggests even permitting animals to cycle up to 23 months of age can limit the risk to only six percent. With careful monitoring, this risk is minimal in dogs and usually surgically curable when caught early.
  7. May mitigate some unwanted behaviors, such as urine marking and male fighting.

What we are also learning, however, is:4,10,12–14

  1. Neutering before the age of one (even up to two years old) in many breeds can be detrimental to growth and can increase the risk of joint disorders, including hip and elbow dysplasia, and cranial cruciate tears. The role of gonadal hormones in growth and development, including in the closure of the growth plates contributes to this risk. Early neutering may allow more time for long-bone growth, causing joint alignment changes.
  2. At the same time, these hormones may offer protective benefits in some tissues; thus, keeping them circulating for longer may protect against cancers in certain breeds. Thus, neutering before the age of one in several breeds can increase the risk of certain neoplasias.
  3. Urinary incontinence can result from neutering, and, in some breeds, the risk of occurrence increases with early desexing.
  4. Early desexing may lead to unwanted behavioral changes (rather than preventing or improving upon them).

    A boxer being examined by a female veterinary professional.
    As a general recommendation, waiting until one to two years of age before spaying or neutering can protect larger and giant breed dogs from joint conditions. GettyImages/GILAXIA

What we don't know or have enough evidence to support

Research on our feline patients is limited. Obesity studies related to neutering felines are prevalent; however, research in other areas is lacking. Additional studies evaluating pediatric vs. standard six-month desexing in cats are needed to better understand the risks they may face and to help determine the best age for desexing owned animals. Pediatric gonadectomy in shelters and rescue situations is not reviewed here. However, current recommendations for six months for males and females still seem reasonable based on current evidence. Pediatric neutering in shelters needs further research to determine whether any detrimental effects occur; however, benefits for population control and adoption protocols to date suggest greater benefit than risk.

In a 2023 study by Hart et al., the authors discuss a study involving 40 different breeds, including mixed breeds, and recommendations for neutering. While this study spanned 10 years, additional research is needed to further support its findings and determine optimal neutering timing. Ultimately, as they suggest, neutering timing should be a decision made between the client and veterinarian, individualized for each patient, breed, and family.10

Needed resources and research

We still need more research to better elucidate neutering timing in dogs and cats. In a PloS ONE scoping review in 2024, authors reviewed five outcomes: atopy, orthopedic disease development, obesity, neoplasia, and urogenital diseases, and concluded that while there is literature out there, additional research is needed to conclusively make recommendations. Until that time, it remains a choice between the veterinarian and client and should be individualized for each patient.16

Further, we need an evidence-based reproductive guideline created by an unbiased group of professionals who systematically synthesize the evidence, including references to the evidence's quality and relevance. We need guidelines developed using stringent and clear procedures for the guideline development committee, including declarations of conflicts of interest and disclosures of support (monetary or otherwise), as well as a recognition of any uncertainties and biases.

Guidelines should reflect the reality of implementing recommendations across geographical regions and populations, and should be created by experts and reviewed by end users (e.g., primary care vets, owners, technicians) to ensure acceptance and understanding. Many veterinary guidelines omit these steps, and we need a set of reproductive guidelines that incorporate all the research in this way to generate recommendations for global use.

General recommendations

Take into account the following when deciding when to neuter or spay a dog:

  • Gender
  • Anticipated adult weight
  • Breed
  • Living situation/lifestyle
  • The owner's concerns for joint-related diseases and cancers

Some general recommendations that came out of the 2023 Hart et al. study, in combination with the literature that came before it, include:10,14,15

  • In larger and giant breeds, waiting until one to two years of age can be protective, especially for joint conditions.
  • For mixed breeds with an expected adult weight greater than 20 kg, it is ideal to wait until one year or older to avoid joint disorders.
  • Small breed dogs generally are at no greater risk for joint-related problems if neutered at six months; thus, for most, this still is a reasonable time for these breeds, with a few exceptions.
  • In shelter situations, neutering small breeds pediatrically has not been connected to joint concerns as they age.
  • For certain breeds, neutering after 23 months is recommended based on high risk of orthopedic or neoplastic conditions.
  • For owners who refuse to neuter despite these recommendations due to risks of neoplasia, cultural or other reasons, but also do not want unwanted pregnancies, gonadotropin-releasing hormone implants or other methods of neutering can be evaluated and discussed, but the risks of pyometra and mammary cancers must be included in that discussion.
An inflamed, pus-filled uterus removed from a 14-year-old miniature poodle during an emergency spay to treat pyometra. Photo courtesy Therese M. Castillo

Don't forget to pexy!

While this is an article about neutering, I would be remiss not to mention the opportunity to discuss neutering with our pet parents. Not only does it provide you with the ability to educate clients about neutering and the benefits, drawbacks, and timing for that individual pet-family, but for breeds at risk of GDV, it is a great time to plant the seed and recommend prophylactic gastropexy (a.k.a. pexy). If you are not comfortable performing this procedure, at least educate your clients about the risks, and if they would like to go with it, offer a referral to a clinic that can provide the service.

Since most high-risk dogs are barrel-chested, large, or giant-breed, this may be between 12-18 months of age or older. All too often on ER I see GDVs in pets, and owners were never offered a prophylactic pexy, a procedure that could save lives and thousands of dollars.

One size doesn't fit all

So, when discussing neutering dogs with pet parents, discuss the research and current thinking behind waiting in certain breeds. Review breed-specific research and recommendations to determine what is right for each breed, considering owners' means, expectations, desires, and understanding. Don't simply establish a hospital policy recommending neutering at six months without considering possible negative impacts this could have on long-term health outcomes.

For cats, nothing in the research to date suggests that the standard five- to six-month timing needs to be adjusted. Regardless, involve your clients in the decision-making process and use the most up-to-date, evidence-based recommendations to support your patients and your practice's reputation.


Erica Tramuta-Drobnis, VMD, CPH, is the CEO and founder of ELTD One Health Consulting, LLC. She works as a public health professional, an emergency veterinarian, a freelance writer, a consultant, and a researcher. Dr. Tramuta-Drobnis is passionate about One Health issues and is a strong advocate of evidence-based veterinary medicine. She is the president-elect of the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medical Association (EBVMA).

References

  1. Romagnoli S, Krekeler N, De Cramer K, Kutzler M, McCarthy R, Schaefer‐Somi S. WSAVA guidelines for the control of reproduction in dogs and cats. J Small Anim Pract. 2024;65(7):424-559. doi:10.1111/jsap.13724
  2. Smith LM, Hartmann S, Munteanu AM, Dalla Villa P, Quinnell RJ, Collins LM. The Effectiveness of Dog Population Management: A Systematic Review. Anim Open Access J MDPI. 2019;9(12):1020. doi:10.3390/ani9121020
  3. Urfer SR, Kaeberlein M. Desexing Dogs: A Review of the Current Literature. Anim Open Access J MDPI. 2019;9(12):1086. doi:10.3390/ani9121086
  4. Romagnoli S. When - and whether - should we spay/neuter companion dogs. J Small Anim Pract. 2025;66(11):761-766. doi:10.1111/jsap.13894
  5. Godfrey H, Morrow S, Abood SK, Verbrugghe A. Identifying the target population and preventive strategies to combat feline obesity. J Feline Med Surg. 2024;26(2):1098612X241228042. doi:10.1177/1098612X241228042
  6. Maniaki E, Murrell J, Langley-Hobbs SJ, Blackwell EJ. Associations between early neutering, obesity, outdoor access, trauma and feline degenerative joint disease. J Feline Med Surg. 2021;23(10):965-975. doi:10.1177/1098612X21991456
  7. Larsen JA. Risk of obesity in the neutered cat. J Feline Med Surg. 2017;19(8):779-783. doi:10.1177/1098612X16660605
  8. Oliveira-Martins M, Portugal M, Cardoso L, Martins-Bessa A. The Impact of Pediatric Neutering in Dogs and Cats-A Retrospective Study. Anim Open Access J MDPI. 2023;13(15):2487. doi:10.3390/ani13152487
  9. Benka VA, Scarlett JM, Sahrmann J, et al. Age at gonadectomy, sex, and breed size affect risk of canine overweight and obese outcomes: a retrospective cohort study using data from United States primary care veterinary clinics. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2023;261(9):1316-1325. doi:10.2460/javma.22.12.0596
  10. Hart LA, Hart BL, Thigpen AP. Decision-Making on Recommended Age of Spay/Neuter for a Specific Dog: General Principles and Cultural Complexities. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract. 2023;53(5):1209-1221. doi:10.1016/j.cvsm.2023.05.005
  11. Guirguis P, Beggs DS. Systematic Review: Does Pre-Pubertal Spaying Reduce the Risk of Canine Mammary Tumours? Anim Open Access J MDPI. 2025;15(3):436. doi:10.3390/ani15030436
  12. Phungviwatnikul T, Valentine H, de Godoy MRC, Swanson KS. Effects of diet on body weight, body composition, metabolic status, and physical activity levels of adult female dogs after spay surgery. J Anim Sci. 2020;98(3):skaa057. doi:10.1093/jas/skaa057
  13. Decreased Energy Needs in Pets After Spaying or Neutering. Purina Institute. Accessed October 1, 2026. https://www.purinainstitute.com/centresquare/life-stage-nutrition/decreased-energy-needs-in-pets-after-spaying-or-neutering
  14. Hart BL, Hart LA, Thigpen AP, Willits NH. Assisting Decision-Making on Age of Neutering for 35 Breeds of Dogs: Associated Joint Disorders, Cancers, and Urinary Incontinence. Front Vet Sci. 2020;7:388. doi:10.3389/fvets.2020.00388
  15. Ribeiro IM, Carvalho RPR, Viana AG de A, Ramirez-Lopez CJ, Silva TB da, Machado-Neves M. Non-surgical sterilization of male animals using sclerosing agents: A systematic review of intratesticular and intraepididymal injection protocols. Reprod Biol. 2026;26(1):101101. doi:10.1016/j.repbio.2025.101101
  16. Moxon R, England GCW, Payne R, Corr SA, Freeman SL. Effect of neutering timing in relation to puberty on health in the female dog-a scoping review. PloS One. 2024;19(10):e0311779. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0311779

 

Comments
Post a Comment

Comments