Conversations around euthanasia are difficult. Developing open-ended inquiries and staying open can help clients with the decision. GettyImages/Mr. Vito A few months after my rotating internship, I landed at a high-touch practice in a beautiful, affluent community. It was a lovely clinic; all the equipment was brand new, and the owners, practice manager, and staff flattered me with great respect and attention. I had just been hired but was already reveling in the position. No longer was I “just” a lowly vet student (or a possibly even lowlier intern); I was ready to be a real vet. To get out there, save lives, and finally unleash all the knowledge I had worked so hard to cram into my telencephalon. I had only been there for about a week when one afternoon, a quality-of-life exam appeared on my schedule. I’ll call the 13-year-old female spayed Westie that walked through the door that day Rosie. Already, a vet tech had asked me for my dose of pentobarbital based on Rosie’s last weight. I had done plenty of euthanasia by then, and I felt prepared for the solemnity and challenge of the conversation ahead. I went in, introduced myself, and asked what was happening. Rosie walked up to greet me, tail wagging and eyes bright. She was old, but she didn’t show any signs of suffering. I was surprised. In retrospect, I would have loved to have been aware that surprise is a cognitive phenomenon whereby a subconscious presupposition is violated by unambiguous environmental conditions within the organism’s detection window¹ (i.e., “things ain’t lookin’ right”). Because if I had, I would have immediately relaxed my body posture, softened my tone of voice, and focused hard on open-ended questions with the client sitting across the exam room from me. I wouldn’t want to have given away my surprise, because I was about to enter a life-or-death struggle with this pet owner. I just didn’t know it yet. No chance The man was tall and elderly, with a gruff manner that matched his tousled white hair. Rosie panted and paced as the owner his seat on the chair and looked at the floor. He looked pained, but not quite in the way you would expect for someone in the throes of despair. Again, had I had even the slightest inkling of communication-based medicine,² I would have known to approach this conversation very delicately: gathering myself for a moment beforehand (prep), and patiently waiting for the client to reveal key details of his relationship to Rosie (pause). But I didn’t. I said something to the effect of, “I’m sorry, I thought she was here for euthanasia? Am I in the right room?” “She is,” the man grumbled, and his brow bristled and tightened like an angry hedgehog. Oh, I thought with surprise, and then I managed to restrain myself from saying out loud, “’cuz she looks pretty good to me!” The owner gave me no time to speak, as he launched into a grumpy rant about how miserable Rosie was. She hated her life, he told me. She had no joy, no spark, no exotic social events on her calendar. All she did was pant and pace and pee everywhere in the house. She was not the dog she had been as a puppy. He wanted to put her down immediately, for her own sake. I was fresh out of school. There was no way I was going to euthanize this dog. Rosie looked way too good to even consider it. Not a chance, I thought. Ignoramus of clinical communication that I was then, I still had a vague feeling telling someone I couldn’t do what they had already contracted in their mind I could do could lead to conflict. I could have stopped. I could have noticed the distance between what I was seeing and what the client was telling me and asked what “miserable” meant to him. I could have gently investigated the lifestyle he and Rosie enjoyed, and wondered aloud which problems seemed most problematic for her quality of life. Instead, I just asked a lot of questions as my face screwed tighter than his. “Was she really in pain?” “Wasn’t she eating just fine?” “Is this really just about the peeing in the house?” I offered testing and other alternatives. It may have all been quite reasonable, but I was offering solutions before I had heard what really mattered. The client didn’t want to run any tests because he knew Rosie was miserable, as anyone could see. I looked at the eager little dog and was completely flummoxed by his words. Neither of us seemed able to get the other to recognize what was so obvious to us individually. Then he got upset. He gestured and asked why I was being so difficult. I told him I wasn’t being difficult. For the next 10-15 minutes, we played verbal tennis with the word “difficult” until he threw his hands up in the air, exasperated. When he realized I was not going to euthanize Rosie, he got up in a huff and walked out with his dog. I felt proud. I had defended Rosie’s life. Hooray, I did it! Or so I thought. Because at that point in my career, I had not absorbed a very important lesson: the client is just as important as the veterinarian in making decisions. I was probably practicing some arrogant version of paternalistic medicine that has been dying out for decades.³ Where I thought I knew best, and that it was my job to only provide treatments within the narrow scope of my exact judgement. By that measure, Rosie leaving the clinic alive looked like a win, but I did not changed the man’s mind. I’d simply pissed him off and sent him to another clinic where Rosie might well have been euthanized. I don’t know, and I wouldn’t find out, or be a part of that decision-making process, because I had fractured trust at a key moment. I had won a battle, but probably lost the war. Staying open Since then, I have had a few of these conversations go better. “Convenience euthanasia” is a dirty word, so I think of them more as … “guardian angel visits.” I get to practice my communication skills at the highest (in my opinion) level. If it works out, the client leaves the appointment feeling heard and understood, and a healthy animal stays alive. The key, as simple as it sounds, is openness. Develop truly open-ended inquiries. No asking what type of dog food they are on, or how many times they have vomited in the last 36 hours. You need to sit down, look people in the eye, and ask what they mean when they say x, y, or z. What do they expect from the appointment? What problem needs solving? That is different from running through a list of multiple-choice questions designed to deliver a precise diagnosis. I remember another owner who brought in an orange tabby cat because it was peeing in the house. The client described the pet as miserable. It did not look miserable to me, but this time I did not lead by saying so. I sat with her and asked what was happening. She started talking, and I began to understand the emotions behind the request. Living with a cat that urinates in the house is hard. There were guilt and shame around even considering relinquishment. She worried he couldn’t handle a cage. I cannot remember every word of that conversation or even place it precisely in the timeline of my career. What stayed with me was the difference in my posture. With Rosie’s owner, I was trying to establish whether he had enough reason to do what he wanted. With the cat’s owner, I was trying to understand what she meant and why the alternatives felt impossible. I did not have to agree the cat was miserable to hear that she was struggling. This is a delicate turn. People may keep coming back to the idea “the decision is already made.” They may have prepared themselves to put down a dog they love and may already be imagining how they will explain that decision to everyone in their lives. You may be in a difficult position where you need to decide if you can be complicit in the decision, but be careful not to violate people’s expectations. Tread very lightly, and learn communication skills like signposting and empathy,² because pulling off this conversation requires an enormous amount of trust. There is no magic phrase that guarantees this will go well, but in my experience, owners are often willing to reconsider euthanasia and look at other options if they feel heard first. That part must come first. I used to think the hard part was having the courage to say no. Rosie’s owner taught me I could say no and still fail to help. The harder part is staying open long enough to understand the person in front of me, especially when I am already sure I know what is right. Greg Bishop, DVM, is a small animal veterinarian and a part-time veterinary technology instructor in Portland, Ore. Dr. Bishop also creates the monthly cartoon series, “The Lighter Side.” The author’s opinions do not necessarily reflect those of Veterinary Practice News. References Reisenzein R, Horstmann G, Schützwohl A. The cognitive-evolutionary model of surprise: a review of the evidence. Topics in Cognitive Science. 2019;11(1):50–74. doi:10.1111/tops.12292. Shaw JR, Coe JB. Developing Communication Skills for Veterinary Practice. 1st ed. Wiley Blackwell; 2024. Igel LH, Lerner BH. Moving past individual and “pure” autonomy: the rise of family-centered patient care. AMA Journal of Ethics. 2016;18(1):56–62. doi:10.1001/journalofethics.2017.18.1.msoc1-1601.