Most homemade cat food recipes are unlikely to provide essential nutrients and some may even contain potentially toxic ingredients.
Those are the results of a study by researchers at the University of California (UC), Davis who looked at 114 recipes from online sources and books written by non-veterinarians and veterinarians. While recipes authored by veterinarians had fewer deficiencies, the study found they were still lacking nutrients. Of the all the recipes studied, 40 percent did not provide feeding instructions and the rest lacked detail or were unclear.
“Only 94 recipes provided enough information for computer nutritional analysis and of those, none of them provided all the essential nutrients to meet the National Research Council’s (NRC’s) recommended allowances for adult cats,” says lead author, Jennifer Larsen, UC Davis School of Veterinary Medicine veterinary nutritionist.
In addition, the study found many of the homemade cat food was lacking concentrations of three or more nutrients, with some missing up to 19 essential nutrients. Further, many recipes provided less than 50 percent of the recommend allowances of several essential nutrients, including choline, iron, zinc, thiamin, vitamin E, and manganese.
The study revealed seven percent of the recipes included ingredients that are potentially toxic to cats, including garlic or garlic powder, onions, and leeks. The recipes also lacked warnings about bacterial contamination of raw animal products and did not mention the importance of grinding up bones to prevent gastrointestinal (GI) tears.
According to Larsen, there was an increase in cat owners switching to homemade cat food recipes after toxic substances were found in commercial pet food imported from China more than a decade ago. Owners may also have their cat on a homemade diet because they want more control over their diet, they believe their cat should be vegetarian, or they want to ensure the diet is sustainably sourced or contains organic ingredients.
Only five recipes from veterinarians met all but one of the essential nutrients. According to the study, whether these recipes would harm cats would vary based on feeding instructions, the length of time the cat has been on the diet, the cat’s health, and the degree of the recipe’s nutritional deficiency.
Larsen advises cat owners consult a board-certified veterinary nutritionist before switching their pet to a homemade diet.
3 thoughts on “Homemade cat food diets low on nutrients”
Yet you fail to mention the extreme toxicity of commercial food, nor the full list of what homemade diets supposedly leave out. Homemade diets of organic raw have no more bacteria than canned or dry food if not left out. Wild cats eat all raw meat with the exception of occasional grasses for digestion.Have the courage to post the diets that did have the “necessary” ingredients. This article stinks of support from the commercial pet food industry and is seriously lacking in fully informative information!
Why should they post recipes for you? If you want to home cook, see a proper, board certified animal nutritionist. And yes, wild cats eat “raw”. They also die. Many die young. I fed my cat a commercial kibble and she lived to be 20 years old. I have no complaints about commercial food.
Johanna, it has been known for decades (yes, that long, and we’re STILL finding serious problems with home-made diets AND raw-feeding). Because you and others fail to discuss the dangers with your vets, thinking you know more than the professional who has spent years in schooling, training, practice and on-going education. These studies are available to pet-owners, those who are not too lazy to look for them. As Testin above rightfully noted, you can talk to a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, who actually know how to form a complete and balanced home-made pet diet. Your vet can also consult one on your behalf. Owners who aren’t proactive enough to discuss with their vets/professionals, are the ones doing the disservice to their pets, not ‘commercial dry food manufacturers’ !!